MCPgrade

MCP server · trust report

io.github.artokun/comfyui-mcp

Published by io.github.artokun

version-controlproductivity

2 checks that ran failed — version behavior and transport config — so this release can’t be trusted as-is.

Publisher
io.github.artokun
Repository
github.com/artokun/comfyui-mcp
Install
npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp, npm:comfyui-mcp
Versions
184
Inspected
5 of 6 checks · 75%
Scored
2026-09-04 · rubric 1.0.0

What we checked

Six static checks, weighted by risk. Every result reflects only what could be observed in the published package and repository — never intent.

6 checks1 clean4 flagged1 not inspected

  • Injection surface

    unscannable25% of grade

    Tool descriptions/manifest scanned for instruction-injection patterns (imperatives at the model, hidden text, 'ignore previous', data-exfil URLs).

    No tool descriptions, server instructions, prompts, or resources were fetched; nothing to scan for injection.

  • Supply chain

    warn25% of grade

    Package provenance: namespace verification, repo linkage, maintainer count, account age, postinstall scripts, typosquat distance.

    install hook "prepare" present and not a recognized benign build command; dependency "yaml" is edit-distance 2 from popular package "yarn" (typosquat candidate)

  • Credential hygiene

    pass15% of grade

    How the server takes secrets (env vs plaintext config vs hardcoded); secrets appearing in tool schemas.

    Reads secrets from the environment (e.g. scripts/arena-baseline.mjs) — the recommended intake shape. PASS = no static red flag; static analysis cannot prove the code honors env-based secret handling at runtime.

  • Permission scope

    warn15% of grade

    Declared tools vs. breadth (filesystem, network, exec); flags shell-exec and unbounded filesystem access.

    has both shell/exec and network egress — capable of download-and-run, though no such path was observed (scripts/check-anti-slop.mjs: imports child_process and calls exec/spawn; scripts/arena-probe.mjs: outbound HTTP/socket call). has both shell/exec and destructive filesystem writes (scripts/check-anti-slop.mjs: imports child_process and calls exec/spawn; scripts/i18n-build-en.mjs: destructive/writing fs.* call (write/unlink/rm/chmod/rename)). discloses shell/exec capability: 15 files (scripts/check-anti-slop.mjs, scripts/check-blog-staleness.mjs, scripts/check-changelog.mjs, +12 more) discloses broad/destructive filesystem access: scripts/i18n-build-en.mjs: destructive/writing fs.* call (write/unlink/rm/chmod/rename) discloses broad/destructive filesystem access: scripts/sync-agents.mjs: destructive/writing fs.* call (write/unlink/rm/chmod/rename) Capability DISCLOSURE, not a verdict: static analysis sees the primitive is present and reachable, not whether its use is attacker-controlled.

  • Version behavior

    fail10% of grade

    Diff of tool definitions between versions; new permissions or changed descriptions in a patch release (the postmark-mcp class).

    vs prior 0.52.179 (patch bump): new capability primitive(s) in source: child_process, fs-write, http-client, net, subprocess; new hardcoded outbound host/BCC destination(s): 127.0.0.1, api.comfy.org, api.runpod.io, auth.docker.io, comfy.example.com, comfyui-mcp.artokun.io, docs.comfy.org, ghcr.io, github.com, hub.docker.com, huggingface.co, openrouter.ai, raw.githubusercontent.com, vendor.example, www.mintlify.com, www.w3.org.

  • Transport config

    fail10% of grade

    Remote servers: TLS and auth mode (none/token/OAuth). Local servers: whether the manifest indicates it phones home.

    source performs runtime self-update / download-and-execute (bypasses version_behavior); manifest/source references tracking behavior — disclosure

Version history

Each release plotted by grade against the safe line at B. A version that sinks below the line has lost its trusted standing — the shape of a rug-pull.

VersionPublishedGradeScoreInspectedChange
v0.52.189 · current2026-09-04 C605/6 · 75%B→C in v0.52.189
v0.52.1792026-09-03 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1702026-09-02 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1652026-08-30 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1462026-08-28 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1392026-08-27 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1272026-08-26 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1032026-08-25 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.892026-08-24 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.672026-08-23 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.532026-08-22 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.452026-08-21 B87.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.232026-08-20 B87.53/6 · 55%C→B in v0.52.23
v0.52.32026-08-19 C605/6 · 75%±0
v0.52.12026-08-18 C605/6 · 75%B→C in v0.52.1
v0.4.12026-05-21 B77.54/6 · 65%±0
v0.52.1782026-09-02 B87.53/6 · 55%±0
v0.52.472026-08-21 B87.53/6 · 55%±0
v0.52.432026-08-21 B87.53/6 · 55%±0
v0.52.322026-08-20 B87.53/6 · 55%—